Would I Lie to You? Teacher Edition — Truth or Complete Rubbish?
Would you know if your co-host was lying to you? Tisha and Rick borrow the brilliance of the British panel show Would I Lie to You? for a no-guest, just-for-fun episode — each tells a story from their life, the other interrogates them, and then they make the call: true, or complete rubbish?
The stories get wild fast. A hundred copies of The Exorcist's Regan hidden around a high school classroom. A Warhammer figurine superglued to a kid's fingers before school. A student left behind on a certification field trip. A screwdriver welded to a live light switch. Twenty speeding stops before 18 — and only one ticket. A microwave pizza explosion. And a bonus round: 23 famous people met completely by chance, from George W. Bush to New Kids on the Block.
Along the way there's a Man United vs. Liverpool whiteboard prank, some Tisha maths, a very strict dad, and a bit of neurodivergent honesty — including why Tisha calls it before Rick's even finished, and why she thinks seeing famous people as just people comes down to how her brain works. It's a great game to steal for your classroom, too: creativity, critical thinking and the art of questioning, all in one.
Keep score at home — neither of them does as well as they think. Tell us in the comments which story fooled you.
00:00 The Unexpectedness of Life
02:58 The Thrill of Storytelling
06:00 Creative Interrogation: Truth or Lie?
11:58 Teaching Tales: Lessons from the Classroom
17:54 The Importance of Accountability
22:24 Half Truths and Believable Stories
27:24 Dangerous Encounters and Life Lessons
28:16 Teenage Speeding and Consequences
39:44 Famous Encounters and Random Meetings
Join the newsletter: https://played3.com/?newsletter=1
📢 Listen and subscribe on your favorite platform:
Spotify | Apple Podcast | Amazon Music | YouTube
📱Follow Play Ed3 Podcast on:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/played3podcast
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/played3podcast
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@PlayEd3Podcast?sub_confirmation=1
🙋♀️Follow Tisha on:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/tishaponcio
X (Twitter): https://x.com/tishaponcio
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@tishaponcio
🙋♂️Follow Rick on:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/rickbutterworth
X (Twitter): https://x.com/r1ck11
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@rickbutterworth
Want to be a guest?: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeCaEyQrrPcYsKdQHaSlFbVXVVC_eNyXMMfy5NTj0aRNcR6Vw/viewform?usp=header
🧠 Let's learn, grow and play together
More Conversations
S2 · EP 21Why Are Teachers Expected to Be Perfect?
Why are teachers expected to be perfect when other professions get room to practice? Rick and Tisha open up the first responses to "What Are You Noticing?", the anonymous section of their new Press…
S2 · EP 19What Ed Tech Gets Wrong About Real Classrooms with Stephanie Howell
What happens when an ed tech insider goes back into the classroom? Rick and Tisha sit down with Stephanie Howell (intervention specialist, instructional coach, Google Innovator, and co-author of…